Why does my data keep coming back? Removal that sticks
You get your details taken off a site, and a few months later they're back. Here's why that happens, and what guardID does to stop it.
In short
Data brokers keep buying and merging new lists, so a deletion only removes the copy they hold today. guardID re-checks and re-sends requests for as long as you're a member, and asks every company to suppress you: to keep a record that stops you being added again. We recommend they keep it as a one-way fingerprint (a hash), so they can block your details without holding them.
Why your data comes back
- Brokers buy lists from each other. If you're deleted from one company but still on another's list, the next purchase brings you back.
- Public sources get re-scraped. The open electoral register, Companies House and other public records are re-imported on each company's own schedule.
- A deletion has no memory. Once your record is gone, the company has nothing to check new data against, so you look like a new person.
How guardID keeps you off
- Removed. guardID sends an erasure request (UK GDPR Article 17) and an objection to direct marketing (Article 21). The company deletes your record.
- Remembered, safely. We ask them to keep only a one-way fingerprint of your details on a suppression list, not your name and address.
- Blocked on arrival. When they buy new data, each record is checked against the list. If it matches you, it's dropped before it reaches their database.
And if a company doesn't suppress?
Not every company keeps a suppression list, and the law doesn't make them use a particular method. That's why guardID also keeps checking for as long as you're a member, and sends a new request whenever your details reappear. Suppression makes that less likely to be needed. Re-checking catches it when it is. And if a company keeps failing to act, and we have enough evidence it isn't a one-off clerical error, we will look to complain to the Information Commissioner's Office on behalf of our affected members.
For the companies we contact
Our guide to hashed suppression explains how a company can honour an objection without keeping readable personal data, with a worked outline of the check.
Frequently asked questions
Because the site re-imports data from public records and other brokers. Deleting your record only removes the copy it held at the time. Unless the site keeps a suppression record, the next import can add you back.
A hashed suppression record can't be turned back into your details. It can only be used to recognise and block them. That's far safer than the readable suppression lists many companies keep.
No. Once your details are in your guardID account, the requests, suppression asks and re-checks happen automatically.